cmoa logo

   CAREER MEDICAL OFFICERS
   Association (now known as ASCMO)

How much is the "Barrier" in the NSW CMO AWARD costing you ?


Last updated 4th Nov 2000

This "Barrier" appears in Clause 4 of the NSW CMO Award:

The Senior Registrar salary is identical to the salary for a CMO 2.1. Therefore CMOs employed as CMO 2.2 & above have all penalty, overtime and public holiday payments calculated on the lower salary ascribed to CMO 2.1.

This graph demonstrates how % loadings for CMOs are eroded as they progress through the various CMO levels. Base hourly rates rise, but Penalty, Overtime and Public Holiday loadings do NOT. This "barrier" restricts all calculations to the CMO 2.1 rate, which can be as many as 6 levels of pay below the CMO's. When other public servants might be entitled to a 75% loading on their normal hourly rate for working on a Sunday, a CMO may get as little as a 57% loading on their normal hourly rate.

The following table displays the consequent hourly reductions in pay NSW CMOs are uniquely obliged to accept, when providing their services during so called "unsociable hours".

If you want this barrier removed then you will need to tell your industrial representatives in NSW .. namely Health and Research Employees' Association of NSW and Australian Salaried Medical Officer's Federation (ASMOF). The CMOA has long requested that this "barrier" be removed. Our own award, has had a distinct clause (#22) inviting these associations to remove it on our behalf, yet 11 years have passed without this being achieved. [click here to view a full copy of the NSW CMO Award]


Why the barrier in NSW CMO Award needs to be removed .. (all figures correct Jan-Dec 2000)
This barrier is uniquely unfair to CMOs, as it not only affects overtime, but also ordinary penalty rates and public holiday loadings.
This table demonstrates the financial impact of this barrier on the hourly rates paid to CMOs during sociable and unsociable hours.
As a CMO rises through each level, this barrier diminishes their effective % loading on their base hourly rate.
    eg: "Double-time" for a Grade 3.3 CMO is not double time, as it only involves a 75.5% loading on their base hrly rate
   
(Jan2000)   Nights    
Base   (excluding     Public
Hourly Evenings W/ends) Saturday Sunday overtime overtime Holiday
Rate 1800-2400 2400-0800     first 2hrs after 2 hrs  
Loading % 0% 12.5% 25% 50% 75% 50% 100% 150%
Sen Reg rate in RMO Award  $   38.64  $   43.47  $   48.30  $   57.96  $   67.62  $   57.96  $   77.28  $   96.61
Grde 2 Yr 1 without barrier  $   38.64  $   43.47  $   48.30  $   57.96  $   67.62  $   57.96  $   77.28  $   96.61
(= Sen Reg rate) with barrier  $   38.64  $   43.47  $   48.30  $   57.96  $   67.62  $   57.96  $   77.28  $   96.61
         effective % loading with barrier         12.5%     25%     50%     75%     50%     100%     150%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $        -    $        -    $        -    $        -    $        -    $        -    $        -  
Grde 2 Yr 2 without barrier  $   39.95  $   44.94  $   49.93  $   59.92  $   69.91  $   59.92  $   79.89  $   99.87
  with barrier  $   39.95  $   44.78  $   49.61  $   59.27  $   68.93  $   57.96  $   77.28  $   97.91
         effective % loading with barrier         12.1%     24.2%     48.4%     72.6%     48.4%     96.7%     145.1%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    0.16  $    0.33  $    0.65  $    0.98  $    1.96  $    2.61  $    1.96
Grde 2 Yr 3 without barrier  $   41.52  $   46.71  $   51.91  $   62.29  $   72.67  $   62.29  $   83.05  $ 103.81
  with barrier  $   41.52  $   46.35  $   51.18  $   60.85  $   70.51  $   57.96  $   77.28  $   99.49
         effective % loading with barrier         11.6%     23.3%     46.5%     69.8%     46.5%     93.1%     139.6%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    0.36  $    0.72  $    1.44  $    2.16  $    4.32  $    5.76  $    4.32
Grde 2 Yr 4 without barrier  $   43.12  $   48.51  $   53.90  $   64.68  $   75.46  $   64.68  $   86.24  $ 107.80
  with barrier  $   43.12  $   47.95  $   52.78  $   62.44  $   72.10  $   57.96  $   77.28  $ 101.08
         effective % loading with barrier         11.2%     22.4%     44.8%     67.2%     44.8%     89.6%     134.4%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    0.56  $    1.12  $    2.24  $    3.36  $    6.72  $    8.96  $    6.72
Grde 3 Yr 1 without barrier  $   44.46  $   50.02  $   55.58  $   66.69  $   77.81  $   66.69  $   88.92  $ 111.15
  with barrier  $   44.46  $   49.29  $   54.12  $   63.78  $   73.44  $   57.96  $   77.28  $ 102.42
         effective % loading with barrier         10.9%     21.7%     43.5%     65.2%     43.5%     86.9%   130.4%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    0.73  $    1.45  $    2.91  $    4.36  $    8.73  $   11.64  $    8.73
Grde 3 Yr 2 without barrier  $   47.07  $   52.95  $   58.83  $   70.60  $   82.37  $   70.60  $   94.14  $ 117.67
  with barrier  $   47.07  $   51.90  $   56.73  $   66.39  $   76.05  $   57.96  $   77.28  $ 105.03
         effective % loading with barrier         10.3%     20.5%     41.0%     61.6%     41.0%     82.1%   123.1%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    1.05  $    2.11  $    4.21  $    6.32  $   12.64  $   16.85  $   12.64
Grde 3 Yr 3 without barrier  $   51.21  $   57.61  $   64.01  $   76.81  $   89.62  $   76.81  $ 102.42  $ 128.02
  with barrier  $   51.21  $   56.04  $   60.87  $   70.53  $   80.19  $   57.96  $   77.28  $ 109.17
         effective % loading with barrier         9.4%     18.9%     37.7%     56.6%     37.7%     75.5%   113.2%
         hourly loss due to barrier    $    1.57  $    3.14  $    6.28  $    9.43  $   18.85  $   25.13  $   18.85
Loading % 0% 12.5% 25% 50% 75% 50% 100% 150%
Base Evenings Nights Saturday Sunday overtime overtime Public
Hourly 1800-2400 (excluding     first 2hrs after 2 hrs Holiday
Rate   W/ends)  
  2400-0800  
[click here to view NSW CMO Award]


Some examples:


COMMENTARY:

Apparently the CMO Award was developed from a variety of existing awards, mainly the Registrar's Award, Community Physician's Award & up to 5 others

The Gradings were largely based on experience. Penalty, Public Holiday and Overtime loadings were limited to the Senior Registrar rate, because Medical Officers senior to Senior Registrars didn't attract a penalty or overtime loading on their hourly rate. [NB: Senior Administrative Medical Officers typically perform the majority of their rostered duty during normal business hours. A situation quite dis-similar to many CMOs who often find the majority of their normal rostered hours outside normal business hours and subject to unfairly restricted loadings.*]

The "Penalty & Overtime barrier" may prevent CMO's above Grade 2 Year 1 from receiving their full percentage loadings on their base hourly rate most of the time!! ie: "unfairly penalised most of the time"

Furthermore, Clause 22 Leave Reserved in the CMO award specifically invites the "Associations to apply ... for the removal of the overtime barrier" .. and has been present in the Award from its inception in 1989.


Has your "association" applied on your behalf ?
Will you ask your "association" to apply on your behalf ?


Appendix:

Relevant excerpts from the NSW CMO Award:

[Click here to view entire PUBLIC HOSPITAL (CAREER MEDICAL OFFICERS) (STATE) AWARD]


 Clause 4.  Salaries:

    Medical Officers in receipt of a salary higher than that of Senior Registrar in the Public Hospital (Medical Officers) Award are to have penalty, overtime and public holiday payments calculated on the salary ascribed to Senior Registrar, as varied from time to time.


 Clause 8.  Penalty Rates:

    Any ordinary hours worked between the following hours shall be paid at ordinary time plus the appropriate penalty rate:

    (i) Hours worked between 6.00 pm and midnight, Monday to Friday - 12½ per cent.

    (ii) Midnight and 8.00 am, midnight Sunday to midnight Friday - 25 per cent.

    (iii) Midnight Friday and midnight Saturday - 50 per cent.

    (iv) Midnight Saturday and midnight Sunday - 75 per cent.


 Clause 10.  Overtime:

    All time worked by officers in excess of the ordinary hours specified in clause 7, Hours of Work, shall be paid at the rate of time and one half for the first two hours, and double time for the remaining hours worked provided that all overtime performed on a Sunday, shall be at double time         


 Clause 13.   Public Holidays:

     (iv) All hours worked on public holidays shall be paid at the rate of time and one half.


 Clause 22.   Leave Reserved

    Leave is reserved to the Associations to apply as they may be advised in respect of Clause 4, Salaries, for the addition of a Grade 4 and in respect of any adjustment to the rates in the Public Hospital (Medical Officers) Award; in respect of Clause 10, Overtime, for the removal of the overtime barrier; in respect of the outcome of matters 781, 807, and 808 of 1989 and before the Commission in Court Session on the issue of lengthy periods of work.

    Leave is reserved to the Corporation to apply as it may be advised in respect of clauses 4, Salaries, 10, Overtime and 20, Long Service Leave, in relation to permanent part-time work.Clause 13.

[Click here to view entire PUBLIC HOSPITAL (CAREER MEDICAL OFFICERS) (STATE) AWARD]




DISCLAIMER:
This page is designed for the sole use of medical practitioners
The information contained within has been provided in good faith.
However, it may contain opinions and errors in fact. Therefore all information is not to be relied upon by any party.

It is presented to stimulate debate amongst the medical profession only

Consult your industrial adviser for clarification.



page maintained by David Brock for the CMOA
email:
davbrock@ozemail.com.au